---
title: Paying for Convexity, or Being Paid for It? Digital Assets in Resilient Portfolios
description: Convexity is the second line of defence after diversification. Tommaso Mancuso explains how digital assets have supplied it without the usual premium.
image: https://blog.3iq.io/hubfs/Podcast%20Graphic.png
---

[![3iQ Header Logo](https://blog.3iq.io/hs-fs/hubfs/3iQ%20Header%20Logo.png?width=114&height=36&name=3iQ%20Header%20Logo.png)](https://www.3iq.io/)

[![3iQ Logo](https://blog.3iq.io/hubfs/3iQ%20Logo.svg)](https://www.3iq.io/)

- [3iQ Managed Account Platform](https://www.3iq.io/qmap)
- Digital Asset Investment Solutions

    - [Digital Asset Investment Solutions](https://www.3iq.io/digital-asset-investment-solutions)
    - [Active Solutions](https://www.3iq.io/actively-managed-solutions)
    - [Passive Solutions](https://www.3iq.io/our-investment-solutions?invest=passive)
    - [Bespoke Solutions](https://www.3iq.io/bespoke-solutions)
    - [Yield Solutions](https://www.3iq.io/yield-solutions)
    - [Our Factsheets](https://www.3iq.io/our-factsheets?invest=passive)
- [Partnership Solutions](https://www.3iq.io/partnership-solutions)
- [About 3iQ](https://www.3iq.io/about)
- News & Insights

    - [Press & Media](https://www.3iq.io/press-and-media)
    - [Insights](https://blog.3iq.io/news-insights)

[Get in Touch](https://www.3iq.io/contact)

[Back to insights](https://blog.3iq.io/news-insights)

![](https://blog.3iq.io/hs-fs/hubfs/Podcast%20Graphic.png?width=720&name=Podcast%20Graphic.png)

 Market insights  |  Digital Assets

# Paying for Convexity, or Being Paid for It? Digital Assets in Resilient Portfolios

Convexity is the second line of defence after diversification. Tommaso Mancuso explains how digital assets have supplied it without the usual premium.

 November 20, 2026

 Author: [Tommaso Mancuso](https://blog.3iq.io/news-insights/author/tommaso-mancuso)

 Social

<https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=%3Cspan+id%3D%22hs_cos_wrapper_name%22+class%3D%22hs_cos_wrapper+hs_cos_wrapper_meta_field+hs_cos_wrapper_type_text%22+style%3D%22%22+data-hs-cos-general-type%3D%22meta_field%22+data-hs-cos-type%3D%22text%22+%3EPaying+for+Convexity%2C+or+Being+Paid+for+It%3F+Digital+Assets+in+Resilient+Portfolios%3C%2Fspan%3E&url=https%3A%2F%2Fblog.3iq.io%2Fnews-insights%2Fpaying-for-convexity-or-being-paid-for-it-digital-assets-in-resilient-portfolios>

<https://www.linkedin.com/sharing/share-offsite/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fblog.3iq.io%2Fnews-insights%2Fpaying-for-convexity-or-being-paid-for-it-digital-assets-in-resilient-portfolios>

<https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCx3LCjlvxRkq5Syq99liUbw>

### Key points

- **In our view, convexity is the second most valuable portfolio attribute, after diversification.** Over a full cycle it helps whether diversification works or fails, though not necessarily within a crisis, and it matters more now that stocks and bonds can fall together, as in 2022.
- **Digital assets have supplied it without the usual premium.** Over the five years to September 2026, Bitcoin’s monthly return skew was +0.50 and a digital hedge fund blend’s +1.15, against −0.28 for the S&P 500 and −0.41 for a 60/40 portfolio.
- **A small sleeve changes the shape of the whole portfolio.** In a hypothetical 60/40, a 5% spot Bitcoin sleeve and a 10% Digital Hedge Funds sleeve both captured more of the up-months than of the down-months, and a 10% Bitcoin sleeve cut negative skew from −0.41 to −0.24.

All figures in this summary are hypothetical or prepared with the benefit of hindsight; past performance is not indicative of future results. See the Disclaimer and exhibit notes.

## The narrative in question: bonds will hedge equities

For two decades, the 60/40 portfolio relied on one narrative: when equities fell, bonds rose. That narrative belonged to a regime of disinflation and falling rates. In 2022 it broke, as the S&P 500 fell 18% and global bonds 16% in the same year. We believe holding a 60/40 today is an implicit bet that the old regime returns.

The evidence since then is not encouraging. Global bonds returned −1.9% a year over the five years to September 2026, against +13.8% a year for the S&P 500 TR. Under fiscal dominance and sticky inflation, rising real yields push stocks and bonds down together. Adding sleeves has not restored the hedge: private equity is public equity with smoothed marks, emerging-market beta rises in stress, and hedge fund composites now carry negative skew (−0.16 for the HFRI Fund Weighted Composite).

We do not argue that diversification is dead. Correlations are cyclical, and the stock–bond hedge may well return. The prudent response is to add a second line of defence that works whatever that correlation does.

## Framework: convexity, second only to diversification

Diversification is the first attribute a portfolio should have, because it cuts risk without giving up return. Convexity is the second. Diversification reduces how much a portfolio moves; convexity shapes how it moves, so that gains in up markets outweigh losses in down markets. The two are additive, so convexity improves a portfolio whether diversification is working or not.

We use three terms throughout. **Convexity** is the shape of the payoff: how much an exposure gains in a large up-move compared with what it loses in an equal down-move. **Skew** is the footprint that shape leaves in the return distribution, measured as the sample skewness of monthly returns; zero is symmetric, positive means a longer right tail. **Up-capture** and **down-capture** are a portfolio’s average return in a benchmark’s up or down months, as a percentage of the benchmark’s.

Most traditional assets are concave by this measure, and digital assets convex. Over the five years to September 2026, equities, bonds, hedge funds and commodities all showed negative skew, from −0.09 to −0.28. Gold was the exception, at +0.77, though a 5% weight in gold left a 60/40’s skew worse (Exhibit 5). Bitcoin showed +0.50, the CoinDesk 20 +0.85 and Digital Hedge Funds +1.15 (Exhibit 1). Digital Hedge Funds is our name for a blend of the NilssonHedge crypto market-neutral and long/short indices, weighted 85/15 so that each contributes equal risk.

Exhibit 1: Digital assets show positive skew on both measures; most other assets negative

![Exhibit-01](https://blog.3iq.io/hs-fs/hubfs/Exhibit-01.png?width=645&height=466&name=Exhibit-01.png)3iQ calculations, 60 monthly returns, October 2021 – September 2026. Log returns scaled to S&P 500 volatility: each asset’s monthly returns scaled to the S&P 500 TR’s volatility, as in a position rebalanced monthly against cash, then converted to log returns. Digital Hedge Funds (NilssonHedge Crypto Market Neutral and Crypto Long/Short indices, 85/15 blend, monthly rebalanced); CoinDesk 20; Bitcoin; gold; Bloomberg Global Aggregate Gross TR; Bloomberg Commodity Index; HFRI Fund Weighted Composite; S&P 500 TR. Hypothetical performance, not the results of any strategy or portfolio. Prepared with the benefit of hindsight. Actual results may differ materially.

## Evidence: what convexity looks like inside a 60/40

A 5% spot Bitcoin sleeve and a 10% Digital Hedge Funds sleeve both captured more of the 60/40’s up-months than of its down-months. Exhibit 2 plots, for each of the 60 months to September 2026, the return of a hypothetical 60/40 against how much a sleeve added or subtracted. A convex sleeve sits above zero on the right, in the 60/40’s good months, or above zero on the left, in its bad months. The 60/40 rose in 37 of the 60 months.

**Exhibit 2: Both sleeves captured more of the 60/40’s up-months than of its down-months.**

![Exhibit-02](https://blog.3iq.io/hs-fs/hubfs/Exhibit-02.png?width=645&height=339&name=Exhibit-02.png)Spot Bitcoin funded from equities, Digital Hedge Funds from bonds. 3iQ calculations, monthly returns, October 2021 – September 2026; monthly rebalanced, net of fees. Each panel: 60/40 monthly return (x) against the sleeve portfolio’s return minus the 60/40’s (y), with a quadratic fit. Hypothetical performance, not the results of any strategy or portfolio. Prepared with the benefit of hindsight. Actual results may differ materially.

The two sleeves deliver convexity in different ways. Spot Bitcoin adds upside: it lifted the 60/40’s up months by 0.15 percentage points (pp) a month on average, at a cost of 0.10 pp in down months. Digital Hedge Funds cushion the downside instead: down-capture fell to 96%, while up-capture held at 102%. Put simply, the first raises the ceiling and the second raises the floor.

## Under the hood: where the convexity comes from, and what options are pricing

One explanation for the positive skew of digital assets, in our view, is ownership. Traditional assets are already widely held in institutional portfolios, while digital assets remain under-owned. In our opinion, adoption will keep that gap open for the foreseeable future.

Bitcoin behaves like a long call option on adoption. When a new group of users arrives, its demand meets a fixed supply and a network effect, and the price reprices quickly and by a large amount. Adoption is the conditioning variable; the network effect, in which each new user raises the network’s value to every other user, is the second-order term. The analogy stops at the downside. A call has a known maximum loss. Between waves, Bitcoin has fallen as much as 73.0% on month-end prices in our window. The limit on loss has to come from the size of the position and from the vehicle (i.e. active management).

The return data show that shape. Over the five years to September 2026, Bitcoin and the S&P 500 TR both returned 13.8% a year. Without each asset’s six best months, the S&P 500 still returned +3.3% a year, while Bitcoin returned −21.0% a year. Over ten years, removing Bitcoin’s ten best months cuts its annual return from 63.6% to 8.2%.

The shape has also been stable. Bitcoin’s five-year skew was positive in all 70 rolling windows since December 2020, between +0.21 and +0.55. The S&P 500 and the 60/40 were negative in all 58 windows since December 2021 (Exhibit 3). In the same 58 windows, a 10% Bitcoin sleeve reduced the 60/40’s negative skew every time, by 47% on average and by 22–79% in the range (Exhibit 3).

The positive skew of digital assets survives a stricter test. Skew in simple returns can flatter a volatile asset, because losses stop at −100% while gains do not. We therefore also scale every asset to the S&P 500’s volatility, as a position rebalanced monthly against cash would be, and measure skew in log returns (Exhibit 1). On that basis Bitcoin shows +0.35, the CoinDesk 20 +0.67 and Digital Hedge Funds +0.93, against −0.39 for the S&P 500 and −0.22 to −0.32 for bonds, hedge funds and commodities; gold showed +0.55. The asymmetry also shows in the extremes: Bitcoin’s five best months averaged +37.9% against −22.4% for its five worst, a ratio of 1.7, against 1.2 for the S&P 500.

**Exhibit 3: In every window, Bitcoin’s skew stayed positive and a Bitcoin sleeve lifted the 60/40’s.**

![Exhibit-03](https://blog.3iq.io/hs-fs/hubfs/Exhibit-03.png?width=645&height=601&name=Exhibit-03.png)3iQ calculations, rolling 60-month skew of monthly returns, windows ending December 2020 – September 2026 (panel A) and December 2021 – September 2026 (panel B). Panel A: Bitcoin; S&P 500 TR; 60/40 = S&P 500 TR / Bloomberg Global Aggregate Gross TR, monthly rebalanced; shaded months: Bitcoin 3-month option skew put-rich (Deribit). Panel B: Bitcoin replaces the 60/40 pro rata. Hypothetical performance, not the results of any strategy or portfolio. Prepared with the benefit of hindsight. Actual results may differ materially.

### Is this realised skew priced into options?

The test is option-implied skew, which measures something else: the price of downside protection relative to upside, not the shape of realised returns. We normalise it as the 25-delta put volatility minus the 25-delta call volatility, divided by at-the-money volatility; above zero means puts are dearer than calls. On that measure Bitcoin is put-rich today, at 0.13, 0.10 and 0.08 for 30, 90 and 180 days on 31 October 2026. That is a third to a fifth of the S&P 500’s 0.43, 0.46 and 0.46 (Exhibit 4).

**Exhibit 4: Bitcoin options are put-rich today, at a third to a fifth of the S&P 500’s level, and move between regimes.**

![Exhibit-04](https://blog.3iq.io/hs-fs/hubfs/Exhibit-04.png?width=1330&height=1200&name=Exhibit-04.png)

Normalised 25Δ option skew. Panel A: by tenor, 31 October 2026 (Bitcoin) and 30 October 2026 (S&P 500), against medians since May 2019. Panels B and C: 30-day and 180-day constant maturity, 21-day rolling median, May 2019 – October 2026. Bitcoin: Deribit, 3iQ surface fit, 09:00 UTC; S&P 500: Bloomberg, US close.

The two markets also behave differently over time. The S&P 500 has been put-rich on essentially every day since May 2019, at every tenor. Bitcoin moves between regimes: its 180-day options were put-rich on only 34% of days, and its 30-day skew was steeper than the S&P 500’s on 0.9% of days (Exhibit 4). Its option skew was put-rich in 46% of the months in Exhibit 3, while its realised skew stayed positive throughout.

Put-rich pricing helps the case for owning convexity. When options price Bitcoin’s upside below its downside, partly because overwriting and yield products sell upside calls, convexity is cheaper to own. A call-rich surface would make for a less attractive entry point. The upshot: option skew tells us what convexity costs today; return skew tells us what it has delivered.

Positive skew is a property of the full cycle, not protection in a crisis. In a liquidity shock, correlations rise and Bitcoin falls with other risk assets. Its maximum drawdown over the five years to September 2026 was −73.0% on month-end prices. That is why we size the exposure small and do not time it on a discretionary basis; where exposure is adjusted, it is done through a systematic, rules-based process.

## Why digital assets have supplied convexity without a premium

In efficient markets, convexity is priced like a tax. The three traditional sources each charge for it, in return or in holding pain:

- **Long volatility** bleeds premium through calm periods, which last longer than crises. The With Intelligence Long Volatility Hedge Fund Index returned 0.9% a year over the five years to September 2026. Its longest stretch below a previous peak lasted 51 months.
- **CTAs** deliver convexity over long arcs, with drawdowns that committees struggle to hold through. The BTOP50 Index returned 7.4% a year over the same five years, including 14.9% in 2022 alone. Its longest stretch below a previous peak lasted 20 months.
- **Tail-risk funds** are insurance, and the premium compounds against the portfolio in every year without a tail event. The With Intelligence Tail Risk Hedge Fund Index returned 3.8% a year over the five years, helped by 17.4% in 2022. From June 2009 to October 2026 it returned −4.5% a year, despite a 38.2% gain in 2020.

Digital assets have not charged that premium. Over the five years to September 2026, Bitcoin returned 13.8% a year with skew of +0.50, and Digital Hedge Funds 7.3% a year with skew of +1.15. Exhibit 5 sets them against the three traditional strategies on the same window.

In a positively skewed asset, high volatility can work in the portfolio’s favour rather than against it, provided the position is small enough to hold through the downside. A sleeve changes a portfolio’s skew only if its moves are large enough to register in the whole. Bitcoin’s 56.2% volatility let a 5% allocation lift the 60/40’s skew from −0.41 to −0.35. The CoinDesk 20, at 68.7% volatility, lifted it further, to −0.25. No traditional alternative in Exhibit 5 came close at a 5% weight. Matching Bitcoin would have taken 40% in tail-risk funds, 46% in gold, 50% in hedge funds or 57% in long volatility; no allocation to commodities up to 60% did it.

Sized for equal risk, the ranking changes. Levered to Bitcoin’s volatility, a 5% CTA sleeve would have added +0.11 to the 60/40’s skew, against Bitcoin’s +0.06. Unlevered, that takes a third of the portfolio. Bitcoin’s advantage is capital efficiency, not skew per unit of risk.

**Exhibit 5: Per unit of capital, spot digital assets moved the 60/40’s skew most.**

![Exhibit-05](https://blog.3iq.io/hs-fs/hubfs/Exhibit-05.png?width=1330&height=860&name=Exhibit-05.png)

3iQ calculations, monthly returns, October 2021 – September 2026; each allocation replaces the 60/40 pro rata. Equal risk: 5% of capital, levered to the volatility of the 5% Bitcoin sleeve. Capital needed unlevered: the weight that gives the same volatility without leverage. Digital Hedge Funds: NilssonHedge Crypto Market Neutral and Crypto Long/Short indices, 85/15 blend. CTAs: BTOP50 Index. Long volatility and tail risk: With Intelligence indices, equal-weighted, USD, manager-reported returns net of fees. Hypothetical performance, not the results of any strategy or portfolio. Prepared with the benefit of hindsight. Actual results may differ materially.

An asset’s own skew is not enough. Gold showed skew of +0.77 on its own, yet a 5% weight left the 60/40 slightly worse, at −0.44. Low-volatility sleeves do a different job: Digital Hedge Funds, at 10.0% volatility, lower a portfolio’s volatility and drawdown rather than lifting its skew (see The 60/40 test).

That upside has a price in drawdown. A 5% Bitcoin sleeve raised the 60/40’s volatility from 11.6% to 12.6% and deepened its maximum drawdown from −22.2% to −24.1%, while lifting the Sharpe ratio from 0.38 to 0.43. Volatility helps only at a size the portfolio can hold through a −73% fall in the sleeve itself.

The reason is structural. The market is large enough to invest in and small enough to stay inefficient. Total market value is about $2.75 trillion, of which Bitcoin is $1.64 trillion (CoinMarketCap, 16 October 2026), approximately 4% of the US equity market. Liquidity is split across more than 100 exchanges, research coverage is thin, and retail, treasury and institutional flows run on different horizons. In our view, skilled managers can build asymmetry through positioning, sizing and drawdown control without paying an option premium.

In our view, digital assets are becoming core infrastructure for the digital economy, and that supports further adoption. Stablecoin supply reached $318 billion by August 2026, and a16z estimates about $9 trillion of adjusted on-chain stablecoin volume in the year to September 2025. Tokenised real-world assets on public blockchains grew 66% in the first ten weeks of 2026, to $23.6 billion.

Adoption arrives in waves, and the waves are the source of the convexity. Of Bitcoin’s ten best months in the ten years to September 2026, eight fell in two adoption waves (Exhibit 6). The other two were recoveries after the 2018 and 2022 drawdowns.

**Exhibit 6: Eight of Bitcoin’s ten best months fell in two adoption waves.**

![Exhibit-06](https://blog.3iq.io/hs-fs/hubfs/Exhibit-06.png?width=1330&height=780&name=Exhibit-06.png)

Bitcoin month-end price, October 2016 – September 2026, log scale; 3iQ calculations from monthly returns. Wave 1 (smart contracts and token issuance), May–December 2017: +950%. Wave 2 (corporate treasuries and payments, then US Bitcoin futures and spot ETFs), November 2020 – July 2025: +740%, including a −73% drawdown between the October 2021 and December 2022 month-ends. Each wave runs from its first top-ten month to its month-end high. The attribution of months to waves is 3iQ’s assessment. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

Three waves are under way, and a fourth is forming. Stablecoins and payments gained a US legal framework when the GENIUS Act was signed on 18 July 2025. The tokenisation of real-world assets puts instruments such as money market funds, stocks and commodities on rails that trade 24/7. Companies and markets are building their business on those rails, including venues that list equities and pre-IPO exposure. AI agents that hold value and settle with each other at machine speed are a natural fit for the same rails.

How these waves become demand for Bitcoin itself is less direct, and here we state a view, not a fact. Stablecoins sit mostly on other networks today: Ethereum and Tron held about 78% of supply on 9 November 2026. In our view, as more assets move on-chain, a portion will be held in Bitcoin or linked to it. Stablecoins are also coming to Bitcoin itself: Tether announced plans for USDT on Bitcoin and the Lightning Network in January 2025. If the value accrues elsewhere, a diversified exposure casts a wider net, provided the tokens are selected actively: the CoinDesk 20 showed skew of +0.85 over our window but returned −1.6% a year.

The convexity will not last for ever. As the asset class institutionalises, it is likely to be priced in. Two signs would show it: lower volatility, which mechanically shrinks skew, and call-rich option pricing, which would mean the market charges for the upside. We believe that holding no digital assets is therefore an implicit bet that the remaining waves have already been priced.

Neither sign has appeared yet (Exhibit 7). Over 36-month windows ending October 2021 to September 2026, Bitcoin’s skew stayed positive in every window, between +0.09 and +0.96, and ended at +0.66. Its volatility did fall, from 81% to 51% a year, but it held at 3.3 to 4.5 times the S&P 500’s and ended at 4.1 times. The jump in mid-2025 is a window effect: it came as the 2022 drawdown months left the sample.

**Exhibit 7: No sign yet that the convexity is being priced away.**

![Exhibit-07](https://blog.3iq.io/hs-fs/hubfs/Exhibit-07.png?width=1330&height=720&name=Exhibit-07.png)

3iQ calculations, rolling 36-month windows of monthly returns ending October 2021 – September 2026. Left: sample skewness of Bitcoin and the 60/40 (S&P 500 TR / Bloomberg Global Aggregate Gross TR, monthly rebalanced). Right: Bitcoin’s volatility divided by the S&P 500 TR’s. Hypothetical performance, not the results of any strategy or portfolio. Prepared with the benefit of hindsight. Actual results may differ materially. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

## Implications for allocators: building the sleeve

From here we turn from asset classes to active strategies, using three 3iQ portfolios. Each targets a different relationship with volatility, summarised below. Digital Hedge Funds serve as the industry benchmark. Inside a 60/40, each portfolio captured more of the up-months than of the down-months, and Alpha Digital (USD) and Digital Growth cut down-capture to 91%, against 96% for the benchmark (Exhibit 8).

| **Portfolio** | **Target** |
| --- | --- |
| Alpha Digital (USD) — minimise volatility | Returns in the low teens a year, with bond-like volatility |
| Alpha Digital BTC class — embrace volatility | Bitcoin holdings that grow by a high single-digit percentage a year |
| Digital Growth — moderate volatility | More than half of the CoinDesk 20’s upside, with less than a quarter of its downside |

Targets are objectives, not forecasts or guarantees. Source: 3iQ fund factsheets, 30 September 2026; five-year figures October 2021 – September 2026, net of fees. Fund performance before December 2025 is pro forma. Hypothetical performance, not the results of any strategy or portfolio. Prepared with the benefit of hindsight. Actual results may differ materially.

**Exhibit 8: 3iQ portfolios against the Digital Hedge Funds benchmark, inside a 60/40.**

**![Exhibit-08](https://blog.3iq.io/hs-fs/hubfs/Exhibit-08.png?width=1330&height=1060&name=Exhibit-08.png)**

3iQ calculations, monthly returns, October 2021 – September 2026; monthly rebalanced, net of fees; line = quadratic fit. Alpha Digital BTC class in USD = (1 + Bitcoin) × (1 + class return in BTC) − 1. Fund performance before December 2025 is pro forma. Hypothetical performance, not the results of any strategy or portfolio. Prepared with the benefit of hindsight. Actual results may differ materially.

### The vehicle decides whether you can hold it

The broad market supplied the shape without the return. Over the five years to September 2026, the CoinDesk 20 showed skew of +0.85 and returned −1.6% a year; Bitcoin showed +0.50 and returned 13.8%. A 5% CoinDesk 20 sleeve, funded from equities, lifted the 60/40’s skew from −0.41 to −0.26, against −0.36 for spot Bitcoin, yet cut its Sharpe ratio from 0.38 to 0.36. 3iQ’s Digital Growth strategy, which targets a greater share of the upside than downside of the CoinDesk 20, showed 28.8% a year over the same period, net of fees.¹ This is why the vehicle and the token selection matter.

¹ Most of the Digital Growth record is pro forma: the strategy launched in December 2025 (see Appendix). Since launch, to September 2026, it returned −4.3% in total, against −16.8% for the CoinDesk 20.

Active management can keep the shape and cut the risk. Over the five years to September 2026, the Digital Hedge Funds benchmark showed skew of +1.15 at 10.0% volatility and a −13.6% maximum drawdown; 3iQ’s Digital Growth strategy showed 24.7% volatility and a −21.3% drawdown. The CoinDesk 20 showed 68.7% volatility and a −77.5% drawdown, so the active strategies carried a seventh to a third of its volatility and a sixth to a quarter of its drawdown. An institution comfortable with a small spot weight could therefore hold a larger convex allocation for similar risk.

Spot exposure is also hard to hold at a fixed weight. Left to drift over the five years, a 5% Bitcoin sleeve ranged from 2.2% to 9.9% of the portfolio, which returned 7.8% a year rather than 8.4%. Our 60/40 tests rebalance monthly, and that discipline is part of the benefit: it sells the sleeve after strong months and buys after weak ones.

### Two engines, one sleeve

The same inefficiency also funds returns that do not depend on price. Market-neutral and relative-value strategies form the stable core; directional strategies add convexity and exposure to adoption waves. Over the 36 months to September 2026, Alpha Digital’s correlation was 0.39 to Bitcoin, against 0.83 for Digital Growth (Exhibit 9). Over five years the gap is similar: 0.29 and 0.13 to Bitcoin and equities for Alpha Digital, against 0.79 and 0.41 for Digital Growth.

**Exhibit 9: Alpha Digital tracks Bitcoin at 0.39; Digital Growth at 0.83.**

**![Exhibit-09](https://blog.3iq.io/hs-fs/hubfs/Exhibit-09.png?width=1330&height=720&name=Exhibit-09.png)**

3iQ calculations, correlation of 36 monthly returns, October 2023 – September 2026, net of fees. Alpha Digital = Market Neutral+ (USD) track, pro forma before December 2025. Bitcoin, CoinDesk 20, S&P 500 TR, Bloomberg Global Aggregate, HFRI Fund Weighted Composite, gold. Hypothetical performance, not the results of any strategy or portfolio. Prepared with the benefit of hindsight. Actual results may differ materially.

The strategies behind the non-directional engine, why the inefficiencies they capture persist, and how much capacity they have are the subject of our companion paper, *Non-Directional Absolute Return in Digital Assets*.

### The 60/40 test

A small sleeve changes the whole portfolio. In this hypothetical test, spot Bitcoin and every 3iQ option improved both skew and Sharpe ratio (return above a 3% risk-free rate, divided by volatility), and the active sleeves did more per unit of risk than spot exposure. The CoinDesk 20 improved skew the most and was the only sleeve to lower the Sharpe ratio. The Digital Hedge Funds benchmark, funded from bonds, improved both too, to a Sharpe ratio of 0.47 and skew of −0.37.

| **Portfolio** | **Return p.a.** | **Volatility** | **Max drawdown** | **Sharpe** | **Skew** |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 60/40 (S&P 500 TR / Global Aggregate) | 7.5% | 11.6% | −22.2% | 0.38 | −0.41 |
| Convexity: 5% spot Bitcoin ETF (IBIT), from equities | 8.1% | 12.5% | −24.0% | 0.41 | −0.36 |
| Broad market: 5% CoinDesk 20, from equities | 7.6% | 12.9% | −24.2% | 0.36 | −0.26 |
| Convexity: 5% Alpha Digital BTC class, from equities | 8.7% | 12.5% | −23.7% | 0.45 | −0.35 |
| Defensive diversifier: 10% Alpha Digital (USD), from bonds | 8.8% | 11.1% | −19.6% | 0.53 | −0.39 |
| Growth with a lower drawdown: 10% Digital Growth, from equities | 9.0% | 11.3% | −19.6% | 0.53 | −0.26 |
| Benchmark: 10% Digital Hedge Funds, from bonds | 8.5% | 11.5% | −20.8% | 0.47 | −0.37 |

October 2021 – September 2026, 60 months, monthly rebalanced, net of fees. IBIT launched in January 2024; earlier months use Bitcoin less IBIT’s 0.25% fee. CoinDesk 20: index returns, before fees. Alpha Digital BTC class in USD = (1 + Bitcoin) × (1 + class return in BTC) − 1. Fund performance before December 2025 is pro forma. Benchmark: Digital Hedge Funds (NilssonHedge Crypto Market Neutral and Crypto Long/Short indices, 85/15 blend). Illustrative portfolio construction, not a recommendation. Hypothetical performance, not the results of any strategy or portfolio. Prepared with the benefit of hindsight. Actual results may differ materially.

Each sleeve should be funded from the part of the portfolio whose job it does. Directional sleeves carry equity-like risk and supply the convexity, so they replace equities. Market-neutral sleeves carry little market risk, so they replace bonds, where their low correlation counts most.

Within the directional sleeves, the vehicle matters as much as the allocation. A 5% spot Bitcoin ETF lifts skew from −0.41 to −0.36, but adds 0.9 points of volatility and deepens the drawdown to −24.0%. The same 5% in the Alpha Digital BTC class adds 1.2% a year rather than 0.6%, for the same volatility. The two engines are complements, not substitutes: one sleeve of each covers both jobs.

### Governance and sizing

The complexity that keeps allocators out is what 3iQ is set up to solve. Counterparty risk sits with the exchange, so 3iQ’s managed-account platform (QMAP) keeps assets off-exchange with BitGo under tri-party arrangements, while managers trade with trade-only permissions in segregated accounts. 3iQ keeps legal and operational control, monitors positions and counterparties 24/7, and can replace a manager without a redemption. The allocator has one onboarding, one set of legal documents and one audit and reporting line.

We size the sleeve by risk contribution inside the alternatives budget, not by capital weight. Many institutions start with a pilot and set the long-term size after watching it across market conditions. As one example of institutional interest, AIMCo disclosed a $219 million position in the shares of Strategy (MSTR), a listed company that holds Bitcoin. The position is in Strategy’s equity, not in Bitcoin itself. This reference does not imply any relationship between AIMCo and 3iQ, or any endorsement of 3iQ or its products.

## Objections, and the limits of the evidence

The strongest case against us deserves a fair hearing. A sceptical allocator would raise the five points below; each has force, and we take them in turn.

- **“Crypto is too volatile.”** Volatility is raw material; what matters is the structure around it. Over the five years to September 2026, 3iQ’s long-biased Digital Growth strategy returned 28.8% a year at 24.7% volatility, with a −21.3% maximum drawdown.² The CoinDesk 20 returned −1.6% a year at 68.7% volatility, with a −77.5% drawdown (net of fees; figures before December 2025 pro forma; hypothetical performance, prepared with the benefit of hindsight).
- **“Bitcoin’s positive skew comes from one cycle.”** Our data hold two non-overlapping five-year windows, and both show positive skew: +0.37 from October 2016 to September 2021, and +0.50 since. The ten best months cluster in two adoption waves three years apart (Exhibit 6). Two windows remain a small sample, and the earlier one predates a liquid, institutional market.
- **“Bitcoin’s option skew is negative.”** Option skew is the price of puts relative to calls, not the shape of returns. Bitcoin’s options are put-rich today, but at a third to a fifth of the S&P 500’s level, and its realised skew stayed positive through both put-rich and call-rich option regimes (Exhibits 3 and 4).
- **“We already get convexity from equities, emerging markets or private markets.”** Those are return drivers, not convex exposures. Their skew is negative, −0.28 for the S&P 500 TR over our window, and their downside is tied to global beta.
- **“What about FTX, custody and regulation?”** The 2022 FTX collapse showed the risk of leaving assets on an exchange that is also the counterparty. QMAP was built to address that, with off-exchange custody, trade-only permissions and 24/7 counterparty monitoring. Industry practice has since moved toward regulated managers, segregated qualified custody, ETF wrappers and clearer rules.

² Most of the Digital Growth record is pro forma: the strategy launched in December 2025 (see Appendix). Since launch, to September 2026, it returned −4.3% in total, against −16.8% for the CoinDesk 20.

Nor are these figures flattered by the point in the cycle. Our five-year window starts one month before Bitcoin’s October 2021 month-end peak, and it ends with digital assets well below their highs. At September 2026, Bitcoin stood 27.8% below its five-year high and the CoinDesk 20 39.2% below, both reached 13 to 14 months earlier (Exhibit 10). Digital Hedge Funds were 4.3% below their high, so the bear market reached active strategies too. The S&P 500, the 60/40 and HFRI, by contrast, ended within 1.2% of highs set a month earlier.

**Exhibit 10: Digital assets end the window well below their highs; traditional assets near theirs.**

**![Exhibit-10](https://blog.3iq.io/hs-fs/hubfs/Exhibit-10.png?width=1330&height=840&name=Exhibit-10.png)**

3iQ calculations, month-end values, October 2021 – September 2026; distance of the September 2026 value from the highest month-end value in the window, including its starting value. Digital Hedge Funds: NilssonHedge Crypto Market Neutral and Crypto Long/Short indices, 85/15 blend. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

Our evidence has clear limits. Sixty monthly observations are a short sample. Skew itself is noisy over 60 months: a bootstrap puts Bitcoin’s 90% range at −0.03 to +0.94, and the 60/40’s at −0.81 to +0.01. Digital Hedge Funds is our own 85/15 blend of two NilssonHedge indices, weighted by their volatility before the window. Those indices average only funds that report publicly, and the market-neutral index had a 0.83 correlation to Bitcoin, so it was not fully market neutral. Fund figures before December 2025 are pro forma, and all portfolio results are hypothetical, built with hindsight. Last but not least, the option-skew snapshot is dated 31 October 2026, one month after the return window closes.

## Conclusion: be paid for convexity while the market still pays

We believe allocators should consider a dedicated convexity sleeve in the alternatives budget, sized by risk contribution and built from both engines. In our view, convexity is the most valuable attribute a portfolio can add after diversification, and over a full cycle it helps whether diversification works or not. Over the five years to September 2026, digital assets supplied it with skew of +0.50 to +1.15, where traditional sources charged a premium for it. A 5–10% sleeve was enough to lift a 60/40’s up-capture above its down-capture in every case we tested.

The main risk to this view is time. HFRI hedge fund returns averaged 18.7% a year in the 1990s, 7.5% in the 2000s and 4.4% in the 2010s, as capital and competition arrived. We expect digital-asset convexity and alpha to compress in the same way as the market matures, and falling volatility or call-rich options would be the first signs. The inefficiency is still there to harvest today, but this is a window, not an arrival point.

## Appendix: methodology and sources

- **Returns, volatility, drawdown, skew and correlation:** 3iQ calculations from 3iQ internal performance records, monthly returns October 2021 – September 2026 (Exhibit 9: October 2023 – September 2026; Exhibit 3: rolling 60-month windows to September 2026; best months: October 2016 – September 2026). Skew is the sample skewness of monthly returns. Volatility is annualised from monthly returns. Sharpe ratio uses a 3% risk-free rate.
- **Indices:** Digital Hedge Funds (85% NilssonHedge Crypto Market Neutral and 15% NilssonHedge Crypto Long/Short, monthly rebalanced; weights equalise each index’s volatility over January 2019 – September 2021, before the return window, at 8.2% and 52.2% a year; the indices are equal-weighted averages of publicly reporting funds, with drop-outs replaced by the index average and no backfilled returns; tables updated 25 October 2026), Bitcoin, CoinDesk 20, S&P 500 TR, Bloomberg Global Aggregate Gross TR, HFRI Fund Weighted Composite, Bloomberg Commodity, gold. 60/40 = S&P 500 TR / Global Aggregate, monthly rebalanced.
- **Capture ratios and quadratic fits (Exhibit 2):** up-capture and down-capture are the sleeve portfolio’s average monthly return in the 60/40’s up or down months, divided by the 60/40’s. Quadratic fits regress the monthly return difference on the 60/40 return and its square.
- **Option-implied skew:** Bitcoin, Deribit option prices with a 3iQ volatility-surface fit, 09:00 UTC daily, May 2019 – 31 October 2026. S&P 500, Bloomberg implied volatilities at US close, May 2019 – 30 October 2026. Normalised 25Δ skew = (25Δ put implied volatility − 25Δ call implied volatility) ÷ at-the-money implied volatility; 30-, 90- and 180-day constant maturity; forward delta, not premium-adjusted.
- **Funds:** Alpha Digital = Market Neutral+ (USD) track, net of fees. Digital Growth, net of fees. Fund performance before December 2025 is pro forma. Actual performance since launch, December 2025 – September 2026, cumulative and net of fees: Digital Growth −4.3%; Alpha Digital (USD) −4.4%; Alpha Digital BTC class −3.8% in BTC terms.
- **Convexity alternatives (Exhibit 5):** BTOP50 Index, BarclayHedge, monthly returns, downloaded 9 November 2026. With Intelligence Long Volatility Hedge Fund Index (Bloomberg WITH415) and Tail Risk Hedge Fund Index (WITH417), equal-weighted, USD, With Intelligence index pages, accessed 9 November 2026; tail-risk since-inception figure June 2009 – October 2026.
- **Adoption events:** Cboe and CME Bitcoin futures launched 10 and 17 December 2017; PayPal crypto service announced 21 October 2020; ProShares Bitcoin Strategy ETF began trading 19 October 2021; SEC approved spot Bitcoin ETFs 10 January 2024; GENIUS Act signed 18 July 2025.
- **Digital economy:** stablecoin supply, CoinMarketCap via Stablecoin Insider, 2 August 2026; stablecoin volume, a16z, State of Crypto 2025 (adjusted for inorganic activity); tokenised real-world assets, DeFiLlama via Cointelegraph, 11 March 2026. Stablecoin supply by network: DefiLlama via Stablecoin Insider, 9 November 2026. USDT on Bitcoin: Tether, 30 January 2025.
- **Market value:** CoinMarketCap, 16 October 2026. **HFRI decade averages:** HFRI Fund Weighted Composite, 1991–2020. **AIMCo:** The Crypto Times, 1 May 2026, citing AIMCo’s Form 13F-HR for the quarter to 31 March 2026.

## About 3iQ

Founded in 2012, 3iQ Corp is a digital asset manager offering institutional investment solutions. It launched QMAP, the first institutional-grade managed-account platform for digital asset hedge funds, North America’s first listed Bitcoin and Ether funds, and the first ETH staking ETF. 3iQ Corp is part of Coincheck Group (NASDAQ-listed).

 Related Content

<https://blog.3iq.io/news-insights/the-institutionalization-of-digital-assets-part-7-going-global-and-the-future-model>

![](https://blog.3iq.io/hs-fs/hubfs/Podcast%20Graphic.png?width=450&height=300&name=Podcast%20Graphic.png)

The Institutionalization of Digital Assets (Part 7): Going Global and the Future Model

Market insights | Digital Assets

October 16, 2026

<https://blog.3iq.io/news-insights/the-institutionalization-of-digital-assets-part-6-due-diligence-and-financial-infrastructure>

![](https://blog.3iq.io/hs-fs/hubfs/Podcast%20Graphic.png?width=450&height=300&name=Podcast%20Graphic.png)

The Institutionalization of Digital Assets (Part 6): Due Diligence and Financial Infrastructure

Market insights | Digital Assets

October 9, 2026

<https://blog.3iq.io/news-insights/the-institutionalization-of-digital-assets-part-5-sizing-the-allocation-and-managing-risk>

![](https://blog.3iq.io/hs-fs/hubfs/Podcast%20Graphic.png?width=450&height=300&name=Podcast%20Graphic.png)

The Institutionalization of Digital Assets (Part 5): Sizing the Allocation and Managing Risk

Market insights | Digital Assets

October 2, 2026

## Disclaimer

This material is intended for sophisticated investors, including institutional and accredited investors, and is provided for informational purposes only. It does not constitute investment advice or an offer or recommendation to buy or sell any investment. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Any hypothetical or illustrative results are based on assumptions and historical data and do not represent actual performance. Digital assets and related strategies involve significant risk, including volatility and possible loss of capital. Diversification and strategies designed to provide convexity do not guarantee a profit or protect against loss.

[![3iQ White Logo](https://blog.3iq.io/hubfs/3iQ%20White%20Logo.svg)](https://www.3iq.io/)

###### Social

- <https://twitter.com/3iQ_corp>
- <https://www.linkedin.com/company/3iq-corp>
- <https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCx3LCjlvxRkq5Syq99liUbw>

###### Contact

161 Bay Street, Suite 2700 Toronto, Ontario Canada M5J 2S1

+1 (416) 639-2130

[info@3iq.ca](mailto:info@3iq.ca)

###### Explore

- [3iQ Managed Account Platform](https://www.3iq.io/qmap)
- [Digital Asset Investment Solutions](https://www.3iq.io/digital-asset-investment-solutions)
- [Fund Factsheets](https://www.3iq.io/our-factsheets?invest=passive)
- [Partnership Solutions](https://www.3iq.io/partnership-solutions)

###### Company

- [About 3iQ](https://www.3iq.io/about)
- [Press & Media](https://www.3iq.io/press-and-media)
- [Insights](https://blog.3iq.io/news-insights)
- [Careers](https://www.3iq.io/careers)
- [Contact](https://www.3iq.io/contact)

© 2026 3iQ Corp. All rights reserved. Investing in digital assets involves risks.  
Please read all offering documents carefully before investing.

- [Preferences](https://www.3iq.io/?_gl=1*1e71f0r*_gcl_au*MTYyODEzMTMzNy4xNzQxNjkwMzc1)
- [Disclaimer](https://www.3iq.io/disclaimer?regions=Canada)
- [Privacy Policy](https://www.3iq.io/3iq-privacy-policy)
- [Cookies Policy](https://www.3iq.io/3iq-cookies-policy)
- [Corporate Governance](https://www.3iq.io/corporate-governance)
- [Legal, Financial & Regulatory](https://www.3iq.io/legal-financial-regulatory)

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Tommaso Mancuso",
    "url" : "https://blog.3iq.io/news-insights/author/tommaso-mancuso"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-11-20T14:39:02.389Z",
  "datePublished" : "2026-11-20T14:15:00.000Z",
  "headline" : "Paying for Convexity, or Being Paid for It? Digital Assets in Resilient Portfolios",
  "image" : [ "https://blog.3iq.io/hubfs/Podcast%20Graphic.png" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://blog.3iq.io/news-insights/paying-for-convexity-or-being-paid-for-it-digital-assets-in-resilient-portfolios",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://blog.3iq.io/hubfs/3iQ%20Logo.svg"
    }
  }
}
```